Home
entries friends calendar user info Goode Trouble Previous Previous Next Next
I Am My Avatar - Microsoft 1, google 0 (... on vanity searches for my own recent shit)
Big Warm Fuzzy Public Heart
boutell
[info]boutell
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
Microsoft 1, google 0 (... on vanity searches for my own recent shit)
A bing search for designing while intoxicated (no quotes required) brings up Rick's P'unk Avenue Window Blog post with that title as the #1 result, no muss no fuss no waiting.

A google search still brings up 500 other irrelevant things. Quote it and you get other pages that mention the phrase independently (fair enough), a whole bunch of pages that link to Rick's post (ooo-kay?), and... not Rick's post, ever, unless you add search terms to force it to look only at our site. Etc. I wrote about this problem ad nauseum already. The sitemap helped for a while, now it doesn't seem to be helping any more.

Ditto for svncampfire, a utility I wrote recently that pings svn repositories for new updates and notifies a campfire chatroom about them (*).

The creepiest result is a search for boutell sonnets. Google brings up my sonnets tag as the #2 result, after my LJ profile, which is okay. Bing brings up the sonnets tag as the #1 result, which is better. But Bing also adds a title:

"A New Sonnet Every Monday"

Whoa! Did somebody really go to the trouble to hand-tune that result? No, of course not. Their indexing system was clever enough to borrow it from a link on tommybgoode.com.

Other searches, some of them less self-serving, also suggest that Bing is doing a remarkable job so far. I'm going to switch to Bing for a week to whether I continue to feel that way. Google could use some serious competition.

(*) svncampfire's big attraction is that it uses the svn log command rather than a post-commit hook, so you can monitor an svn repository you don't run.

Tags: , , , , ,

Comments
yendi From: [info]yendi Date: June 1st, 2009 02:30 pm (UTC) (Link)
I'm not as impressed as you are. A search on "261 days of horror" at Google leads to my blog. A search at Bing leads to a number of those bogus RSS aggregation that leech blog content, a few blogs that point to mine, but not any of my actual posts.

A search for my actual name (sans quotes) shows me a number of my doppelgangers (which is fair), my Twitter and Friendfeed pages, but that's it. At Google, it also brings up my LJ and my Bookslut reviews.

Both results based on what shows up on page 1, of course. Anything that happens after that is irrelevant.
yendi From: [info]yendi Date: June 1st, 2009 03:01 pm (UTC) (Link)
Interestingly, a repeated "261 days of horror" search at Bing leads to my reviews actually showing up. I'll cautiously chalk that up to beta testing and give them another chance.
2 comments or Leave a comment
profile
Tom Boutell
User: [info]boutell
Name: Tom Boutell
Website: Goode Trouble
calendar
Back November 2009
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930
page summary
tags